Group protection insurers risk missing out on the benefits of artificial intelligence unless they improve the quality and accessibility of their customer data, according to Insurtech specialist Lumera.
The company has warned that while insurers are investing heavily in AI to improve efficiency, claims processing and customer services, many still rely on outdated administration systems that could prevent them from realising the technology’s full potential.
With AI tools becoming increasingly accessible across the insurance industry, Lumera believes competitive advantage will depend less on the technology insurers adopt and more on the quality of the information they can use to support it.
The warning comes as group protection providers face growing pressure to demonstrate measurable returns from their technology investments while maintaining the accuracy, security and reliability expected in a highly regulated sector.
Insurers Hold Valuable Data That AI Could Unlock
Group protection providers administer insurance benefits for millions of employees and scheme members, generating substantial volumes of information through quotations, underwriting, enrolments, benefit changes, claims and customer interactions.
This information represents a valuable proprietary resource that could help insurers develop more efficient operations and improve their understanding of customers.
AI has the potential to automate administrative processes, accelerate claims handling, support more accurate risk assessments and enable more personalised communications with members.
It could also help providers identify emerging trends, improve product development and respond more quickly to changing customer needs.
However, Lumera argues that these benefits depend on insurers having access to complete, accurate and well-structured data.
Without reliable information, even advanced AI systems may produce incomplete insights or recommendations that fail to reflect customers’ circumstances.
Legacy Systems Could Hold Back AI Adoption
One of the biggest challenges facing group protection providers is the continued use of legacy administration platforms.
Many traditional insurance systems are organised around policies rather than individual members, making it difficult to build a complete picture of a person’s cover, claims history and changing circumstances.
Information may also be held across multiple systems, creating inconsistencies and making it harder to analyse customer experiences over time.
According to Lumera, these limitations could significantly reduce the effectiveness of AI applications.
For example, AI tools designed to support underwriting or claims assessments require reliable information to identify patterns and produce meaningful results.
Incomplete or fragmented records could undermine those processes, potentially affecting operational efficiency and customer outcomes.
Modern administration platforms that consolidate member-level information could therefore become increasingly important as insurers expand their use of AI.
Data Governance and Customer Trust Remain Essential
The insurance industry’s reliance on sensitive personal and financial information means data quality must be accompanied by effective governance and security.
While AI can support decision-making, insurers must ensure that its use remains consistent with regulatory requirements, appropriate risk management and fair treatment of customers.
Lumera believes providers should prioritise the collection, organisation and protection of member information before attempting to scale AI applications across their operations.
Better-connected data could support more informed underwriting decisions, provide greater insight into claims and help insurers develop products that respond more effectively to customer needs.
However, the company stresses that technological progress must not come at the expense of trust.
As insurers increasingly adopt similar AI tools, their ability to use proprietary data responsibly and effectively may become an important point of differentiation.
AI Technology Alone Will Not Deliver Competitive Advantage
Tim Stoves, who recently joined Lumera as Group Protection Lead, said insurers should focus on strengthening their data foundations rather than viewing AI investment as a solution in itself.
“AI is understandably attracting significant attention across the group protection market, but the industry needs to recognise that the technology itself is only part of the equation. Without the right data foundations, even the most sophisticated AI capabilities will be limited in what they can deliver.
“Over time, AI is likely to become increasingly available across the market and is unlikely to remain a core source of competitive advantage in its own right. The real differentiator will be the quality and completeness of providers’ proprietary member level data, and how effectively they use it to create value, deliver better outcomes for customers and reinforce trust. By connecting information on members’ cover, claims and interactions over time, insurers can build a richer picture of their customers and unlock greater value from AI.”
A Shift in Priorities for Insurance Technology Investment
Lumera’s assessment suggests that insurers may need to reconsider how they allocate technology investment as AI becomes more widely adopted.
Rather than focusing exclusively on acquiring new AI tools, providers could achieve greater long-term value by modernising their underlying administration systems and improving the consistency of their customer records.
This approach could also make it easier to introduce new AI applications in the future, reducing the need to address fragmented data each time a new technology is deployed.
For group protection insurers, the potential benefits extend beyond operational cost savings.
Improved data management could support faster claims decisions, more responsive customer service and the development of products better suited to members’ changing circumstances.
Ultimately, Lumera believes the organisations best positioned to benefit from AI will be those that combine technological innovation with reliable proprietary data, industry expertise and strong governance.
As artificial intelligence becomes a standard feature of insurance operations, the quality of an insurer’s data may prove more important than the sophistication of the AI tools it purchases.
Source: Lumera, 26 October 2026.
Sources and References
Lumera: https://www.lumera.com/